Back Pain Management Options
Richard's troubles began 14-years ago when he nearly collapsed from excruciating pain searing down his leg. His initial diagnosis was a ruptured disk. Since then, even with four major surgeries to repair the problems, his pain has only worsened. Out of desperation, he has tried medications, physical therapies, and pain clinics--all in an attempt to restore some semblance of a functional life.
The Journal of the American Medical Association concluded in a 1996 surgical back pain study that more than $50 billion is spent on the diagnosis and treatment of back pain in the United States. Since the causes are so varied, what works for one person might fail with another.
For most people, drugs work well to control pain and discomfort. But any medication can have side effects. Back pain experts say that over-the-counter, nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs)--including acetaminophen (Tylenol), naproxen (Aleve), and ibuprofen (Nuprin, Motrin IB and Advil)--can be of value in reducing the pain. More severe backpain may require prescription medications such as oxycodone-release (Oxycontin), acetaminophen with codeine (Tylenol with Codeine), and meperidine (Demerol).
Peter Rheinstein, M.D., director of the medicine staff in FDA's Office of Health Affairs, says the many effective NSAIDs available on the market today means there is less need for narcotics. However, he cautions that all NSAIDs cause gastrointestinal bleeding, and advises that patients suffering from other medical conditions need to consult with their doctors about other treatment options for managing their back pain.
"If you have an ulcer, for example, or are taking a blood thinner," Rheinstein says, "you are at an increased risk for gastrointestinal bleeding and should have your doctor prescribe medication that won't aggravate the ulcer or cause any kind of drug interaction."
Exercise and Physical Therapy
Bed rest was once thought to be an effective treatment for back pain, but recently its therapeutic benefit has been questioned. In a study published in the 1996 issue of Spine, Finnish researchers experimented to find out whether exercises to mobilize the back worked better than bed rest. Subjects in the mobility test, who were encouraged to continue normal activities and have no daytime rest, appeared to have better back flexibility by the seventh day than their immobile counterparts, who remained in bed for the duration of the experiment.
"Most people think that a week of bed rest will take away the pain," says David Lehrman, M.D., chief of orthopedic surgery at St. Francis Hospital and founder of the Lehrman Back Center in Miami. "But that's not so. For every week of bed rest, it takes two weeks to rehabilitate."
Vert Mooney, M.D., professor of orthopedic surgery at the University of California, San Diego School of Medicine, says that bed rest for low back pain should be limited to one day and exercise should begin immediately. He explains that exercises which increase flexibility and tone and strengthen muscles can get back pain sufferers up and around by hydrating disks that become painful from loss of fluid. "Exercise can actually pump fluid back into the disk," Mooney says, "and it is important to keep the patient moving so that the disk remains fully hydrated."
However, FDA's Rheinstein says, "For some people, bed rest is just the most comfortable position for the first couple of days."
Spinal manipulation, or "osteopathic manipulative therapy" and chiropractic, are therapies commonly practiced for correcting abnormalities that are thought to eventually cause disease and inhibit recovery. Shields uses this type of manual (hands-on) manipulation technique on the majority of his patients. Occasionally, however, the spasm is too great or the muscles are too traumatized--for example, following an automobile accident or a fall--and the pain or swelling must be "calmed down" using a muscle relaxer for a day or two before hands on manipulation therapy.
Doctors recommend back surgery much less often now than in the past, and only for certain conditions that do not improve after other treatments have been tried. FDA has approved or cleared medical devices such as the Inter vertebral Body Fusion device, Anterior Spinal Implant, and Posterior Spinal Implant to treat degenerative disk disease and stabilize and fuse the spine.
Implantable spinal cord stimulation devices are another aid in the management of chronic pain of the trunk and limbs. These devices electrically stimulate the spinal cord by discharging a one-time or continuous stream of electrical pulses. The implanted portion of the device consists of a pulse generator (which contains an internal power source similar to that used in a cardiac pacemaker) and lead extensions that are connected to electrodes placed in the spinal canal. The non-implanted components of the system include the programming device and screening pulse generator, which are controlled by the physician or patient.
Acupuncture is a centuries-old Chinese healing technique that employs needles placed at specified points on the body. FDA classified acupuncture needles in 1996 as medical devices for "general use" by trained professionals.
The needles are required to have proper labeling, and good manufacturing practices must be followed. Manufacturers must include on the label the statement "for single use only" and provide information about device material sterility and compatibility with the body. The needles must also bear a prescription label restricting use to qualified practitioners as determined by individual states.
Harold Pellerite, assistant to the director of compliance in FDA's Center for Devices and Radiological Health says, "I think today's society is more receptive to alternative medicine. This just points to the need for our agency to be able to have some degree of control over what the American public is exposed to."
Complicating the evaluation of effectiveness of treatment is the fact that most back problems clear spontaneously. How can you tell if the problem was relieved by a particular treatment or if it would have gone away in the same period without treatment? "You really can't," says Shields.
Out of all these options, only two things have given Mettetal any measure of relief -- the Spinal Cord Stimulation System and acupuncture. But, as Shields points out, "One of the most important things to keep in mind is that pain is caused by a variety of underlying problems, and it is naive to think that one treatment option will help improve all back pain conditions."
written by Carol Lewis, a writer in The FDA Office of Consumer Affairs.